Reinforce multilateralism and enhance global governance capabilities

The Rule of Law

Strengthening the rule of law at the national and international level is a core objective of the UN Charter. However, with some limited exceptions, the international legal system has not yet matured into a true rule of law system. Potential reforms to achieve this goal include reforming the peaceful settlement of disputes, the International Court of Justice, and the International Criminal Court and establishing an international judicial training institute and an Office of International Attorney General.
Strengthening the rule of law at the national and international level is a core objective of the UN Charter. However, with some limited exceptions, the international legal system has not yet matured into a true rule of law system. Potential reforms to achieve this goal include reforming the peaceful settlement of disputes, the International Court of Justice, and the International Criminal Court and establishing an international judicial training institute and an Office of International Attorney General.

Only about 40% of UN MEMBER STATES have made a declaration to accept the compulsory jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice (ICJ), including only one permanent member of the UN Security Council. Yet, under the UN Charter, the ICJ is the “principal judicial organ” of the United Nations—it is sometimes referred to by the general public as the “World Court.” The international community should focus expert attention on taking the next steps in the court’s evolution.

The ICJ should be an enhanced institution, more fitted to 21st Century conditions and demands, and over time become a mandatory, universal court, such that all UN Members are subject to its compulsory jurisdiction, as argued by various states at the original Charter negotiations.

The aspiration of international “peace through law” is at the very core of the new, post-war order conceived with the development of the 1945 UN Charter. As a foundational instrument for a reformed international order, the Charter sketches a path for the maturation of an international legal order that adjudicates and settles issues that may disrupt a durable international peace.

However, the current systems still fall short of effective governance institutions that can ensure sustainable peace. The literature on this topic is deep with a common theme, noting that “the conditions necessary for peace are less observable than the discrete nature of wars,” and thus the latter are highlighted more in mainstream study. Establishing a strengthened international legal order—and then maintaining the same—is a project that requires widespread acceptance. Fortunately, this acceptance already broadly exists among many countries that are too often caught between the politics of global and regional powers.

To achieve an enhanced system to protect a sustainable peace – at this crucial juncture in international history with resurgent geopolitical tensions – the international community should consider returning “back to basics” with respect to developing a more modern infrastructure for a strengthened, reliable international rule of law. This, for example, would involve reinforcing key legal institutions such as International Court of Justice (ICJ), also making it an obligatory, universal court of justice as was hoped for by the legal architects of the Charter.

This next-generation institution could be augmented by establishing a modern and well-resourced international judicial training institute that focuses on judicial formation for skill, knowledge and impartiality, conferring yet greater legitimacy on the judiciary of the ICJ as well as the judiciaries of other international courts and tribunals. Further, an Office of the UN Attorney General could be considered, to assist with the building of renewed international order more firmly based on the international rule of law.

Latest Articles

The Rule of Law Visionaries

Bertha von Suttner
Indefatigable Promoter of Peace

Baroness Bertha von Suttner (1843 to 1914) was an Austrian pacifist and writer. In 1905, in recognition of her lifelong opposition to war she was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, the second female Nobel laureate, after Marie Curie.

Other Organizations to Look at

This book’s trenchant analysis of what ails the running of the globe should be read by policymakers everywhere, and certainly by those many citizens who concern themselves with fostering a better and more functional world. Change comes slowly, but this book is a prodding catalyst.

Robert I. Rotberg, Harvard Kennedy School, author of On Governance

Other Areas of Interest

Join the Conversation

Sign up to stay in touch and learn more about the Global Governance Forum.

Stay Up to Date